Silk appointments are a reminder that expertise still shapes dispute resolution

Danny Jovica
November 17, 2026
In Australian commercial mediation, senior advocacy experience continues to matter. The appointment of Glenn Casement SC and Emma Peppler SC as Senior Counsel in Victoria is not only a professional milestone for two barristers; it is also a useful reminder of the role high-level forensic judgment plays in resolving disputes before they consume years of litigation.

Senior Counsel appointments recognise barristers whose skill, independence and standing place them among the leaders of the profession. For parties in mediation, that expertise can be especially valuable when the dispute involves complex evidence, difficult legal risk, multiple decision-makers or the prospect of contested hearings.

Glenn Casement SC brings more than two decades at the Bar, having been admitted in 2001 and signing the Bar roll in 2003. His experience appearing in numerous trials as sole defence counsel points to the kind of courtroom judgment that can sharpen a mediation strategy: knowing which arguments will withstand pressure, which factual disputes matter, and where compromise is commercially sensible.

Emma Peppler SC’s practice in planning, environment and property-related matters across administrative, commercial, common law and criminal jurisdictions is equally relevant to modern dispute resolution. These disputes often involve overlapping statutory duties, expert evidence, government decision-making, project risk and significant commercial consequences.

For Australian commercial parties, the lesson is straightforward. Mediation is most effective when the people in the room understand both settlement dynamics and litigation risk. A persuasive position paper is useful; a clear-eyed assessment of what may happen in court or tribunal is often decisive.

This is particularly important in property, planning, environment and commercial disputes, where legal rights may sit alongside timing pressure, reputational concerns, financing constraints and operational disruption. A mediator can help parties negotiate constructively, but informed advocacy helps parties negotiate realistically.

For mediators, senior counsel involvement can improve process discipline. It can narrow issues, clarify evidence, test assumptions and assist clients to move from positional bargaining to risk-based decision-making. The best outcomes often emerge when strong advocacy and skilled mediation work together rather than against each other.

The forward-looking takeaway for Australian disputants is that mediation is not a softer alternative to legal rigour. It is a forum where legal rigour can be applied earlier, more commercially and with greater control over outcome. As Victoria’s Bar continues to recognise senior expertise, parties should be equally deliberate about bringing the right expertise into the mediation room.

If your commercial dispute would benefit from structured negotiation and experienced mediation support, contact Mediator Life at https://mediator.life/contact.

Sources:
- Foley’s List — Glenn Casement SC and Emma Peppler SC named Silk