Pre-mediation registration is becoming a serious settlement issue in Australian class actions
Danny Jovica
November 19, 2026
Australian mediation depends on parties having enough reliable information to negotiate sensibly. That principle becomes difficult in large class actions, where the respondent may know the size of its customer or member base but not know how many people actually fall within the pleaded class.
The REST superannuation class action is a clear example. The claim concerns alleged deductions for default income protection insurance from inactive member accounts between 5 December 2008 and 30 June 2019. REST could identify roughly 950,000 inactive accounts, but could not determine from its own records how many members also held income protection insurance through another fund, or were unemployed or not receiving income during the inactive period.
That uncertainty matters because class action mediation is not just about legal risk. It is also about participation rates, quantum, administration, release terms and fairness to absent group members. If the parties cannot estimate the size of the compensable group, a mediation may become a contest of assumptions rather than a structured negotiation.
The Federal Court has ordered a pre-mediation registration process so potential class members can identify themselves before mediation. The court accepted that registration will not capture every eligible member, but treated a reliable baseline as preferable to entering mediation without a workable estimate of class size or exposure.
For Australian commercial mediators, the ruling reinforces a practical point: settlement design starts well before the mediation day. In complex disputes, the mediator and parties need to understand what information is missing, whether it can be obtained from existing records, and whether a pre-mediation process is needed to make bargaining rational.
For trustees, insurers and other organisations managing large customer or member populations, the case is also a records warning. If internal systems cannot answer who may have been affected, when, and by what amount, the organisation may lose control of the settlement timetable and face court-ordered steps before negotiation can properly begin.
For applicants and respondents alike, pre-mediation registration should not be treated as a mere procedural tactic. It can shape settlement value, group member communication, confidentiality, opt-out strategy, late claims processes and the court’s assessment of whether any proposed compromise is fair and reasonable.
The Australian takeaway is straightforward: where class size is uncertain, mediation preparation must include a disciplined evidence plan. The better the data before the first joint session, the greater the prospect of a settlement that is commercially realistic, court-approvable and durable.
If your organisation is preparing for a complex commercial mediation or class action settlement discussion, contact Mediator Life at https://mediator.life/contact.
Sources:
- Insurance Business Australia Legal Insights, “950,000 accounts and no way to count the class: court orders REST super fund to act”
- Parkin v Boral Ltd
The REST superannuation class action is a clear example. The claim concerns alleged deductions for default income protection insurance from inactive member accounts between 5 December 2008 and 30 June 2019. REST could identify roughly 950,000 inactive accounts, but could not determine from its own records how many members also held income protection insurance through another fund, or were unemployed or not receiving income during the inactive period.
That uncertainty matters because class action mediation is not just about legal risk. It is also about participation rates, quantum, administration, release terms and fairness to absent group members. If the parties cannot estimate the size of the compensable group, a mediation may become a contest of assumptions rather than a structured negotiation.
The Federal Court has ordered a pre-mediation registration process so potential class members can identify themselves before mediation. The court accepted that registration will not capture every eligible member, but treated a reliable baseline as preferable to entering mediation without a workable estimate of class size or exposure.
For Australian commercial mediators, the ruling reinforces a practical point: settlement design starts well before the mediation day. In complex disputes, the mediator and parties need to understand what information is missing, whether it can be obtained from existing records, and whether a pre-mediation process is needed to make bargaining rational.
For trustees, insurers and other organisations managing large customer or member populations, the case is also a records warning. If internal systems cannot answer who may have been affected, when, and by what amount, the organisation may lose control of the settlement timetable and face court-ordered steps before negotiation can properly begin.
For applicants and respondents alike, pre-mediation registration should not be treated as a mere procedural tactic. It can shape settlement value, group member communication, confidentiality, opt-out strategy, late claims processes and the court’s assessment of whether any proposed compromise is fair and reasonable.
The Australian takeaway is straightforward: where class size is uncertain, mediation preparation must include a disciplined evidence plan. The better the data before the first joint session, the greater the prospect of a settlement that is commercially realistic, court-approvable and durable.
If your organisation is preparing for a complex commercial mediation or class action settlement discussion, contact Mediator Life at https://mediator.life/contact.
Sources:
- Insurance Business Australia Legal Insights, “950,000 accounts and no way to count the class: court orders REST super fund to act”
- Parkin v Boral Ltd